The Naipaul Question
In V.S. Naipaul's writing on Conrad, we see who he truly is.

By Morgan Meis

In a typical brain-spasm of deep insight, James Wood once wrote that V.S. Naipaul “is a writer who has a conservative vision but radical eyesight.” This, in an essay for The New Yorker a few years ago.The World Is What It Is: The Authorized Biography of V. S. Naipaul by Patrick French had just come out. The literary world was agog. Naipaul, never shy to air controversial opinions or disreputable thoughts, had given his biographer total access to his private life. This created some surprises. One surprise was a revelation about Naipaul’s affair with an Argentinian woman in the early 1970s. Here’s how George Packer described the episode in his review of the biography for The New York Times:

Naipaul and Margaret began an affair that set free all of his desires and fantasies. When his editor and friend Diana Athill scolded him, he replied, “I am having carnal pleasure for the first time in my life, are you saying I must give it up?” Carnal pleasure meant violence — in fact it was inextricable from beating Margaret up, degrading her in bed, turning the great man’s penis into an object of worship. How do we know these things? Because Naipaul tells them to his authorized biographer. “I was very violent with her for two days with my hand; my hand began to hurt. . . . She didn’t mind it at all. She thought of it in terms of my passion for her. Her face was bad. She couldn’t appear really in public. My hand was swollen. I was utterly helpless. I have enormous sympathy for people who do strange things out of passion.”

Reading French’s biography, some praised Naipaul’s honesty. Others felt disgust. It has always been so with Naipaul. He splits opinions, drives a wedge into what might otherwise be polite literary conversations. Nearly everyone who has read Naipaul has strong feelings about him. No side ever fully wins the debate. The Naipaul Question has been a live one for more than forty years.

Continue Reading...

•   Joyce's "Finnegans Wake," out loud
•   Blogger Andrew Sullivan dishes
•   An animated lesson in right from wrong
•   50 of the world's most translated books
•   The jazz-lover-turned-writer
Pop Studies
Buddy Up From buddy comedies to world peace?
Much Hinges The joys of using the "wrong comma"
Guinea Pig If you tattoo a pig, is it still just a pig?
Laughing Heathens Atheism doesn’t have to be so angry. Look at Democritius and Santayana.
Loopy Numerology The twisting journey from faithlessness in Philip Levine's "28"
Lost & Found
In the Ground In Narayan's The English Teacher, writing with, and for, the dead in the background.
Lost & Found
Whistlin' Dixie W.J. Cash explored the divided mind of the South: romanticism and violence.
Idle Chatter
Deep Discounts Red Grooms' kooky transcendence defines, and solves, the problem with Pop Art.
Most Viewed
- On 50 years of Rankin and Bass' Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer. By Colin Fleming
- Life – and Emerson – tried to lure the naturalist John Muir back to the world. But his home was always the American wild. By Stefany Anne Golberg
- I had morning milking duty at my Hershey, PA boarding school. But when I went back to see the cows, they were gone. By Albert DiBartolomeo

Available Smart Set RSS Feed
Looking for a Smart Set article?